Haunted by the memory of Walter Holderlin, a soldier he killed during World War I, French musician Paul Renard (Phillips Holmes) confesses to a priest (Frank Sheridan), who grants him absolution. Using the address on a letter he found on the dead man's body, Paul then travels to Germany to find his family.
As anti-French sentiment continues to permeate Germany, Dr. Holderlin (Lionel Barrymore) initially refuses to welcome Paul into his home, but changes his mind when his son's fiancée Elsa identifies him as the man who has been leaving flowers on Walter's grave. Rather than reveal the real connection between them, Paul tells the Holderlin family he was a friend of their son, who attended the same musical conservatory he did.
Although the hostile townspeople and local gossips disapprove, the Holderlins befriend Paul, who finds himself falling in love with Elsa (Nancy Carroll). When she shows Paul her former fiancé's bedroom, he becomes distraught and tells her the truth. She convinces him not to confess to Walter's parents, who have embraced him as their second son, and Paul agrees to forego easing his conscience and stays with his adopted family. Dr. Holderlin presents Walter's violin to Paul, who plays it while Elsa accompanies him on the piano.
The film's original title, The Man I Killed, was changed to The Fifth Commandment to avoid giving "wrong impressions in the minds of the public about the character of the story." It ultimately was released as Broken Lullaby.
作为一个院线级剧场版，结果剧情表现力和文本感染力却还不如原本的静态文本ppt，足以说明这部做得有多拉了。
英灵都是哑巴！！！！！！！不说话就算了，出来连个大招都不让人家放完！！！！！！
互相救赎真美好。但是等了一个小时才牵手亲亲可急死我了😅😅还有结尾是个啥呢…………
可以从第七章到终章看出来cw整个制作组对fgo不能叫毫无关心只能叫没得感情。领钱打卡，花钱我就做，只能说型月下次别做动画了，这两年除了hf和卫宫饭、1.6下剩下的都是些什么臭鱼烂虾，hf虽说和原作对比剧本人设有问题，但人家ufo的音乐画面可是顶中顶，fgo动画这边好家伙，能听的只有游戏原作就有的bgm，原创音乐就一个金闪闪ed能听，剩下的拉中拉，画面也是拉中拉
唯一让我觉得好的，就是咕哒用临时术式召唤出从者战斗，这一点动画改编的不错。我对fgo的改编动画真是不抱什么希望了。
女主长着一张大学生or从大学毕业没几年的脸，却演刚从high school毕业的准大学生…… 片名和海报明明已经把氛围带出来了，剧本却使劲拖后腿。东一榔头，西一棒槌，什么都没讲清，更别说讲好…… 评论说俗套，俗不等于烂啊，看这类片就是图夏夜、大海、沙滩、轻松、浪漫等等。哪怕只图氛围，这片也没做好
看到一半我寻思为啥我对这部剧情了如指掌，以至于内心毫无波动，原来是我玩过FGO啊，还一起打过魔神柱，之前完全忘了……
这啥玩意啊，嘴炮了有1个小时吧，真的让我看得又累又无聊……
一颗星是给00的。。有作为一个人类好好地死去啊(･･;)
好多英灵出场啊，但是一点也不热血啊。。。没有声优
在每个夏夜里，我们乘着黄昏和晚风游荡。夏日氛围真的太太太美好了，认识了一群朋友，也发生过那么多的故事。
用有限的生命，面对死与断绝的存在。
全程快进跳着看完的拉胯剧场版……让我搜索重新看了一眼终章游戏流程🚬
金闪闪的镜头太少了，出场的英灵太多，战斗场面倒是够燃，但是剧情真的是有点看不大懂，到底咋回事啊，一会所有英灵都出来了，假的所罗门给英灵们强制驱散了，然后又全回来了，这个主角也是个王者，酱油王
真是烂，fgo剧情还是这么烂，全程毫无意义的对话，出一大堆英灵出来打酱油，然后主角平A就打赢，真是搞笑啊。
本来半年前就可以在FES看到的……情怀+1★。前半的剧情处理得还是可以的，开场盖总对王的独白到找玛修谈心一路情绪直接绷不住了QAQ “去收集星辰吧” 之前也在想终章大家集结那段会怎么处理，结果为了CV表着想（？）来的英灵竟然基本都没开口【。】后半进神殿就感觉有点emmm了剧情冲击力完全不如游戏当时的震撼啊（以及玛修的那段独白也是盖总，略出戏【×】医生的那段表现得也有点太过于轻描淡写了然后还真就表演了个master手撕盖总啊这实在是…… 话说最后为啥还强行总结升华主题！？游戏完全没这么尬好吧……（但是！一定要！看完片尾啊啊啊———
ohno是真的有点无聊的😴😴明明汇集了夏天 友情 大海 邂逅那么多浪漫因素却还是那么无聊 55非常想念千禧年时代的美式青春电影………
怎么照游戏差那么多，游戏是哭着打完的，剧场版是如此的苍白...
哈？都这场面了为什么不全用5星。。。然后全自来水？
剧情删改不知所云，作画演出烂成一坨。游戏里最高光的部分之一就改成了这种东西，K48。
Copyright © 2015-2023 All Rights Reserved
